Eek--sorry I'm late to the party! Hope it's not too late for me to share my first experience watching the show...
I remember summer of 2007 I had just discovered the Anita Blake Vampire Hunter series, and was hooked on those books--one of my best friends was telling me about this vampire show that was coming out in the fall that I also might like. I distinctly remember telling her, No way was I watching it. Antia Blake was all the vampire I needed. Famous last words.
The day the show aired, I was browsing imdb and I saw an ad for this vampire show called "Moonlight"--it was really cool--it was this pretty good looking guy standing in front of a full moon. The ad intrigued me and I decided that night to watch. I was instantly hooked.
I LOVED the opening scenes, Mick's interview, the shot of him sitting up in his freezer and injecting the blood. I thought it was really interesting and very cool how they were changing the vampire mythos. Plus, the lead actor was really hot!

(what also really amuses me is that at this point I was 100% all about Mick--my love of Josef gradually came on--it's funny, with every show I watch, I intially have one favorite character, but then it inevitably shifts to a different character.) While I thought some parts were kinda cheesy, I still loved the episode and decided to keep watching.
Also, I loved that in the soundtrack was Evanesence. "My Immortal" is one of my favorite songs.
It's been one giant thrill ride ever since, and my friend never misses an oppertunity to say "I told you so!"
And Alle--I am so jealous!! It sounds like you had an AMAZING time--I'm so happy for you! (and did I mention jealous?

)